Tragic Arrogance

The List (PLST) #ORI-38 · Rare · Sorcery

Mana cost: {3}{W}{W}

For each player, you choose from among the permanents that player controls an artifact, a creature, an enchantment, and a planeswalker. Then each player sacrifices all other nonland permanents they control.

The spear thrown by Kytheon's own hand was the weapon that felled his friends.

Illustrated by Winona Nelson · Released December 2, 2024

Prices

Nonfoil price since August 29, 2026: down $0.03 USD (7.5%) to $0.37 USD; low $0.37 USD, high $0.40 USD.

Printings

  1. Marvel Super Heroes Commander #144 (MSC) · Rare · 2026 · $0.18 USD
  2. Marvel Super Heroes Commander #323 (MSC) · Rare · 2026 · $0.39 USD
  3. Secrets of Strixhaven Commander #182 (SOC) · Rare · 2026 · $0.32 USD
  4. Final Fantasy Commander #258 (FIC) · Rare · 2025 · $0.20 USD
  5. Pioneer Masters #363 (PIO) · Mythic · 2024
  6. The List #ORI-38 (this printing) · Rare · 2024 · $0.37 USD
  7. Commander 2021 #109 (C21) · Rare · 2021 · $0.35 USD
  8. Magic Origins #38 (ORI) · Rare · 2015 · $0.33 USD
  9. Magic Origins Promos #38s (PORI) · Rare · 2015 · $3.78 USD foil

Legality

Rulings

  1. 2015-06-22 · wotc — None of the chosen permanents are targets of Tragic Arrogance.
  2. 2015-06-22 · wotc — If a permanent has more than one of the affected types, it can count for any of them. For example, you could choose an artifact creature as the artifact you're sparing, another creature as the creature, and an enchantment creature as the enchantment. Similarly, you could choose an enchantment creature as both the creature and the enchantment that you're sparing, even if the player controls another creature and/or another enchantment.

Played in these commander decks

  1. Quintorius, History Chaser · in 39% of 49 decks
  2. Terra, Herald of Hope · in 33% of 48 decks
  3. Sergeant John Benton · in 14% of 50 decks
  4. Brenard, Ginger Sculptor · in 6% of 50 decks

All cards in The List (PLST)